Hey everyone! I need help with something. I'm writing a section of a book that relates to a "What If" scenario. I am writing a Death Brawl section in a book on Wattpad. What is "Death Brawl"? It's just like Death Battle and Deadliest Warrior. I basically take two major characters from different books and I analyze everything about them before deciding with one would win a fight against each other to the death. Hence, Death Brawl. Now I already have the characters that I want... But I like both of them so much that I can't decide who would win the fight. That's why I need help. Here are the details:

PS: Both of these characters are Werewolves.
Setting: The galleon "Flying Wolf"
Scenario: Serena steals Blaise's necklace that her grandfather gave her and wants it back and wants to teach Serena a lesson.

Combatant 1:
Name: Blaise Pryde
Age:18
Status: Alpha of Lupus Pack
Relationships: Married to Kayle Trassak
Abilities: Shape-shifter, Telepathy, Seasoned Hand-To-Hand Fighter, Very agile
Weapons: Teeth, Claws, Mind Tricks
Traumatic Events: Physical torment by her parents in dark environments, Death of her parents, Constant nightmares and flashbacks
Domination Quote: "Don't steal from me again, not that you can now."

Combatant 2:
Name: Serena Fisher
Age 18
Status: Pyrate Captain of the "Flying Wolf" (I'm not giving into account of homefield advantage)
Relationships: Married to Duke David bar Seaon
Abilities: Water Bending(Basic), Expert Thief, Expert Swordsman, Novice Gunner
Weapons: Teeth, Claws, Water Pack(It's the only water she is allowed to bend), Pyrate Saber, Single Shot Flintlocks(2)
Traumatic Events: Time in jail, Being stuck in a high place, Near and at death experiences
Domination Quote: "Stupid mutt, I grew up fighting."

It's all up to you now. Comment on who you think would win and what is the reason why. Thank you all and I'll post it when it's all written up.